I’d like to pose this question to all those teachers and educators out there – “Are you getting the best out of your kids in the classroom?” I’m not talking about great NAPLAN results, marks on an exam or an ATAR score – I’m talking about reaching the kids in your class and making a connection substantial enough for you to believe they have some chance of reaching their potential, both academically and personally.
I have been a teacher for more than 20 years and it’s only now that I realise I have probably missed the boat on many occasions. Why now? Because for the past six years I have been working outside the classroom, with parents, students and teachers on areas of education I knew very little about while I was on the inside – too busy to scratch myself, let alone keep up with current research on what makes kids tick; what it is we should, but often don’t know, in terms of their state of development and their state of mind. Yes, we teachers know all about curriculum; all about the pressures of performing; all about the million and one administrative tasks we must perform – but how well do we know our clients? The kids in our classroom? Do we ever have enough time to simply chill and find out how special each kid in our class really is – even the naughty ones?
We talk about the mental health and well being of our young, and we often associate that notion with a mental health ‘issue’ such as depression, destructive behaviour, bullying, self-image or binge-drinking disorders. What I’m seeing in classrooms is the pressure to achieve or be damned – pressure from schools, pressure from parents and pressure from peers. If that isn’t a trigger for a mental health issue, I don’t know what is.
A frighteningly real example of this was shared with me only recently – a mum of a Year 7 student could see that her son was struggling with all the changes of secondary school. He wasn’t doing any homework, he wasn’t talking, he was withdrawn and moody. The atmosphere at home was ripe for constant arguments. This mum has visited her son’s school on several occasions to see how she might support her son and to find out how his teachers were dealing with his total ‘disconnect’. She was told by more than one of his Year 7 teachers that “he is a nice boy who behaves well in class. I just don’t have time to chase up every child who doesn’t complete work. There’s too many kids, not enough time and we expect them to take more responsibility for their learning once they start high school.” It’s a clear failure in our education system when we are prepared to admit that heavy curriculum loads and the drive to get through it all results in ‘sacrificial lambs’ who can’t cut it.
I don’t blame the teachers, I blame the system. Our kids spend 13 years of their lives at school – 5 days a week, 42 weeks a year. If they don’t like school (and most of them don’t), why don’t they like it…and who cares if they don’t? Surely there must be something wrong with a system that most kids hate! Why don’t kids get up in the morning and say “Wow! Another day at school – I wonder what new thing I’ll learn today”? They don’t say it because, in general, they find WHAT they are being taught boring. Maybe, just maybe, it’s not WHAT is being taught that’s boring, it’s HOW it’s being taught. It’s been a long time since I completed my degree and diploma, but staff sessions I’ve run on how to tap into the kids in our classes have been met with “I didn’t know that!” from young and not-so-young teachers alike. If I know it because I’ve read it (because now I have the time I didn’t have as a teacher!) then why don’t ‘new’ teachers know it as part of their training?
I am 100% with Sir Ken Robinson whose presentation on schools killing creativity is a must-see for every teacher concerned about the life-long impact they are making on their students. We are so pressured into pushing kids through an over-crowded (and some would argue irrelevant) curriculum that we don’t have the time to inspire kids to learn and create just because they can – and our pressure rubs off on them.
As Ken Robinson says “We are educating kids out of their creativity”; and he further claims that intelligence is diverse, dynamic and distinct. It seems as plain as the nose on your face and basic to any knowledge or understanding of the principles of teaching that we DON’T all learn the same way and teaching should accommodate that; boys and girls are wired differently, so their learning needs are different as well.
I’m sure there are plenty of individual teachers and schools whose approach to teaching and learning fits the philosophy that education is NOT a one size fits all. But, as a ‘system’ and in general, we don’t have time. Those 5 year-olds who head off to ‘big’ school for the first time this year will be retiring in 2067, if they work till they’re 60. How can we educate them for jobs or careers that don’t even exist yet? Yes, we need to teach the basics of literacy and numeracy, but wouldn’t it be better to focus on taking our time and stimulating the capacity that is within every child to create and achieve something, rather than pushing kids through a curriculum, which leads to ‘failure’ for some….or worse, kids not caring at all.
We need to release the pressure valve; teachers need to be allowed to enjoy what is one of the most valuable roles on offer and kids need to be allowed to enjoy learning and creating. If we focused more on how we deliver the message rather than on how much we deliver, we might just find our kids connect better with school and develop a better attitude towards learning – surely a plus for improved mental health in the classroom.
Author: Angie Wilcock , director of High Hopes Educational Services, works with parents, teachers and students. She lives in Sydney and you can view her work at www.highhopes.com.au email: highhopes627@gmail.com
I so agree with everything you are saying. My son is in year 8 this year and completely disengaged. He sees no value in most of his subjects and he has been getting into trouble for talking too much in class and not working. His teachers say its his fault and if he just sits down, is quiet and does his work then there wont be an issue. The blame has all been placed on him and the teachers and school are not willing to take any responsibility. The only one who can change the situation is him, they say. What about using different teaching styles? Giving him a voice in his own learning? Finding out why he is disengaged- and creating value for him to be engaged. I am left frustrated and angry after a school meeting this morning with my sons teachers all playing the blame game and who do they blame- my son and take no accountability at all.
Unfortunately, Jodie, what you are saying is echoed far too often – I’m sorry, I know that doesn’t make you feel any less frustrated.
All I can suggest you do is to to work with your son – one thing I often speak with parents about is confronting a problem from a different ‘angle’. Your son can’t see the relevance of what he is learning at school and shows little interest in classwork…and probably homework as well. Going in on another angle means explaining to him that while he might not see the CONTENT of what he is learning as relevant or interesting, the SKILLS he is learning – like listening to instructions and following them, planning his work, making sure he is on-task – are all skills he will need when he is working for a boss later in life! If he doesn’t listen, follow instructions etc – the boss will find someone else to do his job!
This is the kind of relevance that makes sense to kids – give it a try! If it helps to change his attitude just a bit, it’s worth it!
Hi Jodie and Angie
All I can say is “ditto” to both the article and your comments Jodie. I have been thinking these things for some time now. My son is in Yr 8 and in exactly the same situation. It is infuriating and frustrating and despite my efforts (like yours) to discuss this with the school (teachers and principals), nothing has changed in since Yr 7. I have talked to my son about the skills he is learning (as you mentioned Angie) as opposed to the actual content and it has made a slight difference to his attitude. I wish you all the very best with your son Jodie. Yours in frustration, Sarah
I so agree with everything you are sayingnow-a-day kids are go school they are not sit in the class if they sit they are trouble to the other kids. they are playing & talking with other teacher are seeing him .they dont take interest on them
I’ve just taken my 9 yr old daughter out of the mainstream system. Large class sizes, grumpy over dictatorial teachers, to many tests and no space/time for creativity and individuality.
She now attends a small bush school in Victoria ‘Candlebark’ and in just 6 weeks delights in going to school every single day. The difference; engaged, respectful teachers that interact and model a can do attitude that inspire her. Lots of creative play, art ,music , languages plus the mainstay of a curriculum.
I have no doubt I have done the right thing, this experience will change her life .
I do believe teachers need supporting, classes need to be smaller and respect for the individual needs to return.
Thankyou